The Florida Supreme Court ruled Monday that the retrial of a former Jabil executive charged with killing his estranged wife and her friend can move forward.
4 Months Ago
4 Months Ago
4 Months Ago
Patrick Evans’ case came to a halt last year after the state’s highest court ruled only unanimous juries can sentence defendants to death and that the current law requiring a 10-2 jury vote for the death penalty can’t be applied to pending trials.
Pinellas Circuit Judge Joseph Bulone ruled in October that the trial could go forward as long as jurors were told that, if Evans was convicted of the murders, all 12 of them must vote unanimously to send Evans to death row.
Evans’ attorneys from the Pinellas-Pasco Public Defender’s Office disagreed and filed an emergency petition with the Florida Supreme Court.
"It is not a court’s job to write the law," the petition reads. "There cannot be a fair trial when there is not a constitutional law in place to follow."
In the opinion released Monday, the justices explained that even though the current death penalty statute needs to be revised, most of the law "can be construed constitutionally and otherwise be validly applied to pending prosecutions" as long as the jury unanimously finds the defendant can be sentenced to death.
The State Legislature is expected to pass a new statute this session.
Five justices concurred with Monday’s opinion. Chief Justice Jorge Labarga wrote that the "unconstitutional portion" of the current law that requires a 10-2 vote can be "separated from the rest" of the statute.
Two justices dissented in part. Although Justice Barbara J. Pariente agreed that the trial phase of a death penalty case could move forward, she disagrees with having sentences imposed without a revised law. Justice Peggy A. Quince concurred.
"What remains uncertain is whether additional appellate issues will be created by penalty phase proceedings conducted without benefit of a new statute," Pariente wrote.
Before his arrest, Evans was a Jabil vice president earning a six-figure salary and was married to Elizabeth Evans, a sales director. She later filed for divorce. On Dec. 20, 2008, she went on a date with a co-worker, Gerald Taylor. Later that day, authorities said, Evans confronted them inside her Gulfport condo and shot them dead.
In 2011, a jury convicted him on two counts of first-degree murder. The next year, a circuit judge sentenced him to death.
But in November, the Florida Supreme Court overturned his conviction, citing errors in a detective’s testimony and criticizing a prosecutor’s remarks.
A hearing to set a new trial date is scheduled for Tuesday morning.
Contact Laura C. Morel at lmorel@tampabay.com. Follow @lauracmorel.
Our editors found this article on this site using Google and regenerated it for our readers.
